Boston has been hearing it all year long: Chris Sale is a shoo-in for the AL Cy Young Award. Well, it now appears that we have all witnessed, what may be, the most massive jinxing in recent Red Sox history. If you’re the type of person who cares about accolades (unlike Sale), it’s not looking very good.
On Tuesday night, against the Toronto Blue Jays, Sale unofficially tossed away his Cy Young bid. The sinewy lefty went just 5 innings, giving up 5 ER’s while allowing 8 hits (4 HR’s) and 2 BB’s. This ugly “Sale Day” start was downright exasperating. That’s because he could have practically materialized a Cy Young Award with a solid outing. Instead, Red Sox fans have been left with a nonplussing shoulder-shrug of a not so grand finale.
Meanwhile, over in Cleveland, Corey Kluber, Sale’s most formidable contender for the AL Cy Young Award, has crossed the finish-line like it was a preemptive victory lap.
Neck and Neck
Chris Sale, the workhorse of this Red Sox pitching staff, has appeared sort of over-encumbered lately. Perhaps the ambitious comparisons to Pedro Martinez have finally gotten to him, or maybe it’s the asphyxiating media presence, or it could just be a “thing”. But in his last 3 starts, Sale has not performed like the ace that Boston could depend on earlier in the year.
He’s not an emotional dude. His “stuff” on the mound is the gateway to this man’s soul.
A 4.45 ERA with a WHIP of 1.26: These are the telling numbers from Sale’s last 3 starts. Going into Tuesday night, He had a collective 2.75 ERA and a .946 WHIP. Considering that he recently became the first AL pitcher since 1999 to record 300 strikeouts, it seemed that a requisite quality-start could almost guarantee him the Cy Young. But after Tuesday’s debacle, Sale has a disproportionate ERA of 2.90 and a .972 WHIP. At best, he will have one more chance to polish the back of his baseball card, before CYA voting begins.
Disclaimer: This by no means represents a “bad” season. It’s just mathematically not as good as the season that Corey Kluber has had.
Contrasting Sale’s sputtering, it has been business as usual for Kluber, through the month of September. He’s gone 3-0 in his last 3 starts. During that stretch, he has not allowed an earned run. Over the course of those 23 innings, Kluber’s WHIP is nearly immaculate at .696. With presumably one more start left before the postseason, his 2017 stats are definitively Cy Young worthy: He has a 2.27 ERA (best in the AL) and his WHIP is .861 (best in the AL). If there are still some doubters out there, Corey Kluber also has a record of 18-4. How could you argue against this guy winning the Cy Young?
The Eye Test
Yes, some vehement Fenway-faithful may still suggest that Chris Sale is the best pitcher in the AL, despite what has been a disappointing finish to his season. And that’s not a totally uneducated contention: He has reminded Boston of what it’s like to have a Pedro-esque bulldog at the front of the rotation.
Sale has had a helluva year - the type of year that we haven’t seen since, well… Pedro in 1999. But Chris Sale doesn’t have to win the Cy Young Award to crystallize his undeniably special talent or his importance to this promising Red Sox team.
Fans should be greatly heartened by Sale’s maiden season in Boston. Remember how guys like Josh Beckett and John Lackey started out here? Chris Sale at 28 years old, is already infinitely better than both of them combined; Beckett and Lackey both went on to win a World Series with the Sox. In fact, Pedro Martinez’s first year in Boston is statistically the most comparable to Sale’s: In 1998, Pedro had a 2.89 ERA with a WHIP of 1.091. And how’d he end up working out for us?